In 1941, William Montgomery McGovern, then Professor of Political Science at Northwestern University, wrote a brilliant book entitled From Luther to Hitler, challenging the prevailing assumptions of the chattering classes of his time. His view turned out to be prophetic, yet has received remarkably little attention since.
For a century preceding the World Wars, delusional liberals had been predicting that the world was moving inexorably toward the triumph of democracy and representative government. This delusion took hold in nineteenth-century Europe and was among the themes explored in Dostoyevsky’s parable The Grand Inquisitor. Dostoyevsky was an Orthodox Russian, a reformed liberal, and a survivor of imprisonment and Siberian exile who had lived through and seen far too much to believe this kind of nonsense. I heartily recommend the parable, told by Ivan Karamazov in The Brothers Karamazov, to my fellow readers, and I will not spoil the story beyond that. Suffice it to say that Dostoyevsky, still the world’s greatest novelist, was profoundly skeptical of the notion that human nature and the forces of history were propelling us toward some modern utopia. Like any good Orthodox Christian, he was never one to confuse our brief stay in this troubled world with something that could be molded into the kingdom of heaven.
Read Full Article: https://amgreatness.com/2026/11/20/the-great-american-delusion/