Virginia Gov. Abigail Spanberger’s first-day executive order revoking her predecessor’s mandate that the state cooperate with Immigration and Customs Enforcement, and a follow-up order that state agencies end their ICE agreements, may have played a role in a woman’s murder.The Democrat suffered blowback in March over the “bitter fruits” of her decision, as former Virginia GOP Attorney General Jason Miyares put it, when an illegal immigrant with a lengthy violent rap sheet – arrested, charged and released by Fairfax County months earlier without notifying ICE – allegedly stabbed Stephanie Minter to death Feb. 23.
While congressional Republicans grilled Fairfax County officials this spring over their sanctuary policies – a designation rejected by the allegedly fifth-richest county in America – their pending minority status leaves the GOP unable to move legislation to strip federal funding from sanctuary jurisdictions or authorize victims to sue officials for releasing their attackers.
Minter’s estate is stepping into the breach with a pioneering wrongful-death federal lawsuit against Fairfax County Sheriff Stacey Kincaid and Board of Supervisors, which oversees the police department, setting a template to hold sanctuary jurisdictions financially responsible for the violence that flows from “aiding, abetting, and facilitating illegal aliens.”
“This action is not based on a failure to more aggressively prosecute [Abdul] Jalloh in 2025; nor is it a claim that Defendants violated some free-standing duty to prevent crime,” says the lawsuit by Cheryl Minter, the victim’s mother and administrator of her estate.
“It does not rest on an assertion that Congress has compelled assistance to federal immigration authorities,” but rather “that long ago Congress criminalized assistance to illegal aliens,” the suit also reads.
County officials bear “common-law liability for solicitation and facilitation” of illegal immigrants under federal law, as defined by the Supreme Court in 2023, through their “joint conspiracy to nullify federal immigration laws,” according to the suit.
“Sanctuary policies are a fad, a talking point, and a progressive ploy to win votes –and they cost Americans their lives,” said Leigh Ann O’Neill, chief legal affairs officer for America First Policy Institute, which is representing Minter’s estate. “Stephanie Minter deserved more from her elected officials. Angel families across the country deserve more.”
Two-tiered justice: kid gloves for illegals, stiff penalties for U.S. citizens
The litigation puts heat not only on the county and Sheriff Kincaid, who was blasted in a report last month by House Judiciary Committee Republicans for ignoring nearly 1,700 ICE detainers in two years and terminating ICE agreements as early as 2018, but also on Commonwealth’s Attorney Steve Descano, identified as a “co-conspirator” with the defendants.
Descano has been under fire since Jalloh allegedly murdered Minter because the CAO, as his office is known, had dropped violent charges against Jalloh before the stabbing.
ABC 7 on Friday touted its expose of county police warning Descano “at least three times in writing” that Jalloh could kill someone if the CAO kept dropping charges against the career criminal. CAO “dropped nearly every charge” among more than 30 arrests.
The county got caught with more egg on its face after Descano’s prosecutorial choices with regard to Jalloh were revealed.
The Department of Homeland Security, which includes ICE, called out the county in March for not handing over a 19-year-old illegal immigrant who somehow got enrolled in a district school and was then charged with groping female students over several months. A judge denied Israel Christopher Flores-Ortiz’s request to be released on bail, which the CAO had approved.
Descano’s office is under Justice Department investigation for such seemingly two-tiered justice, in which district attorneys shield noncitizens from immigration consequences while throwing the book at U.S. citizens accused of the same crime.
A GOP House Judiciary report last month found over 100 illegal immigrants, previously unknown, who received kid glove treatment from Descano’s CAO when arrested for crimes including DUI, felony drug possession and larceny, and assaulting law enforcement. Most reoffended and some escalated to violent crimes including murder.
The county Board of Supervisors, sheriff’s office and CAO did not respond to queries about the lawsuit.